TheGunMag – The Official Gun Magazine of the Second Amendment Foundation
  • Home
  • ABOUT US
    • COLUMNISTS

Grassroots Judicial Report—November 18, 2026

Posted By GunMagStaff On Wednesday, November 18, 2026 05:00 AM. Under Featured  
TANYA METAKSA

By Tanya Metaksa

What’s New—U.S. Supreme Court: Viramontes v. Cook County, No. 25-238, and Grant v. Higgins, No. 25-566 — The Court granted the solicitor general’s request to participate as amicus curiae and for divided argument; The Reload: An interview with attorney Alan Beck examines Connecticut’s historical arguments in defense of its AR-15 ban; Gator’s Custom First Circuit: Marshall v. Blanche, No. 25-1721 — A firearms-disability challenge returns for further consideration. Why does the standing analysis matter, and what remains on remand? Guns: What has happened to the pending magazine-ban challenge? Fifth Circuit: Knife Rights, Incorporated, v. Blanche, No. 25-10754 — A split disposition in a Second Amendment challenge to the Federal Switchblade Act. District of Maryland: United States v. Montgomery County, Maryland, No. 8:26-cv-03025 — DOJ’s sensitive-places suit dismissed.

U.S. Supreme Court

Viramontes v. Cook County, No. 25-238, and Grant v. Higgins, No. 25-566

The Supreme Court granted the solicitor general’s request to participate as amicus curiae and for divided argument in the consolidated challenges concerning bans on AR-15s and similar semiautomatic rifles. Oral argument remains scheduled for Wednesday, Dec. 2.

The Reload’s interview with attorney Alan Beck

In a podcast published by The Reload, attorney Alan Beck, who won Wolford v. Lopez at the Court in 2026, analyzes Connecticut’s brief defending its AR-15 ban.

Beck argues that the English gun restrictions Connecticut cites predate the U.S. Constitution and that the state’s explanation of why those laws were enacted is “misleading.”

What has happened to Gator’s Guns?

The Second Amendment community has spent the past five months discussing Viramontes and Grant, two cases before the U.S. Supreme Court. But three other cases remain pending: Gator’s Custom Guns v. Washington, Duncan v. Bonta, and National Association for Gun Rights (NAGR) v. Lamont.

According to William Kirk of the YouTube channel Washington Gun Law, those three cases will probably remain on hold until Viramontes and Grant are decided. He expects decisions in late June or early July 2027.

Gator’s Custom Guns challenges Washington’s restrictions on magazines capable of holding more than 10 rounds and raises the question of whether those magazines receive Second Amendment protection. The Washington Supreme Court upheld the restriction on two principal grounds. First, it concluded that magazines holding more than 10 rounds are not “arms” within the Second Amendment’s text, reasoning that a semiautomatic firearm can remain functional without that capacity. Second, according to Kirk, the court required evidence that people typically fire more than 10 rounds in actual self-defense encounters before treating those magazines as presumptively protected.

In a YouTube video, Kirk focuses on Gator’s Custom Guns while briefly discussing the other two cases. He predicts that the Supreme Court will ultimately grant the petitions, vacate the lower-court judgments, and remand the cases for further consideration—a disposition commonly called a “GVR.”

In Gator’s Custom Guns, that would mean returning the case to the Washington Supreme Court to reconsider its analysis in light of the anticipated U.S. Supreme Court decisions. Kirk expects that process to begin around the summer of 2027, with further state-court proceedings potentially occurring later that year.

The reconsideration Kirk describes would not amount to a Supreme Court decision on the merits declaring Washington’s magazine restriction unconstitutional. For now, Gator’s Custom Guns and the other two cases remain in a holding pattern, awaiting further Supreme Court action and potentially additional litigation in the lower courts.

Court of Appeals

New Hampshire: First Circuit

Marshall v. Blanche, No. 25-1721: Firearms-disability challenge returned for further consideration

The First Circuit issued its decision in Thomas Marshall’s challenge arising from the denial of a firearm purchase based on prior Massachusetts DUI convictions.

IssueRuling
Pre-enforcement challenge to criminal prosecution for possessing a firearmMarshall’s allegations did not establish standing. He had not alleged, expressly or by reasonable implication, that the firearm he intended to possess had traveled in interstate or foreign commerce—the nexus required for § 922(g)(1)’s possession prohibition.
Challenge to the firearm-purchase denial and related background-check measuresThis challenge could proceed on remand. The denial of his attempted purchase supplied a distinct basis for the litigation.
Continued force of Torres-RosarioFollowing the First Circuit’s intervening decision in United States v. Levasseur on September 16, 2026, the district court could no longer rely on Torres-Rosario to dispose of the claim without conducting the analysis required by Bruen.
Ultimate Second Amendment meritsUnresolved. The court vacated the dismissal; it did not invalidate § 922(g)(1), facially or as applied to Marshall.

Why the standing analysis matters

The opinion’s most distinctive feature is its insistence that an intended course of conduct match what the challenged criminal statute actually prohibits. Saying “I intend to possess a firearm” was insufficient here because § 922(g)(1) does not criminalize possession of every firearm without regard to its connection to interstate or foreign commerce.

The panel declined to infer that connection merely from Marshall’s intention to buy a handgun or long gun. It noted that New Hampshire had at least 30 federally licensed firearm-manufacturing facilities in 2023. Although the court acknowledged that most firearms have traveled interstate, Marshall had not adequately developed an argument connecting that general reality to his particular intended possession.

That was a ruling about pleading and standing, not a general declaration that an in-state purchase makes firearm possession lawful. The opinion separately explained that federal sales and background-check provisions can restrict a transfer regardless of whether the particular firearm traveled interstate.

What remains on remand

The district court must reconsider the surviving challenge under Bruen, rather than treating Torres-Rosario as dispositive. It must also consider the significance of the Justice Department’s firearm-rights-restoration process under 18 U.S.C. § 925(c). The panel noted that regulations now permit applicants such as Marshall to seek relief and that his predicate misdemeanors were not among the offenses requiring a heightened evidentiary showing under those regulations.

The narrow takeaway: Marshall reopens an individualized Second Amendment challenge to a DUI-based purchase disqualification while imposing a specific interstate-commerce pleading requirement on the separate pre-enforcement possession theory. It is not a merits holding that DUI-based disarmament violates the Second Amendment.

Texas: Fifth Circuit

Knife Rights, Incorporated, v. Blanche, No. 25-10754: Second Amendment challenge to the Federal Switchblade Act. This case presents a Second Amendment challenge to the Federal Switchblade Act’s restrictions on switchblade knives.

The court stated:

“We determine that switchblade knives qualify as “Arms” and are covered by the “plain text” of the Second Amendment. Because the regulation implicates the amendment, the government bears the burden of establishing that the FSA comports with well-established principles of the Second Amendment and its regulatory tradition. The government fails to meet its burden.

“Accordingly, we conclude that this regulation violates the Second Amendment. We REVERSE the district court’s grant of the government’s motion to dismiss as to the § 1242 claim. We AFFIRM the district court’s dismissal of the § 1243 claim, and we REMAND for further proceedings.”

Why this matters: The decision distinguishes between the two statutory claims. It reverses dismissal of the § 1242 claim, affirms dismissal of the § 1243 claim, and remands for further proceedings. It does not uphold the district court’s dismissal in full.

District Court

U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland

United States v. Montgomery County, Maryland, No. 8:26-cv-03025: DOJ’s sensitive-places suit dismissed

Judge Theodore D. Chuang dismissed DOJ’s challenge to the county’s restrictions on carrying firearms within 100 yards of specified places of public assembly. The court held that DOJ had not alleged an actual law-enforcement “pattern or practice” sufficient to proceed under 34 U.S.C. § 12601; enactment of the ordinance itself did not supply the missing allegations. The dismissal was with prejudice, and the court denied the requested preliminary injunction without deciding the underlying Second Amendment merits.

Why this matters: The decision addresses DOJ’s statutory enforcement authority, not whether the county’s sensitive-place restrictions satisfy Bruen. For civil-rights litigation, its broader importance lies in the obstacle it places before DOJ’s effort to use a police-misconduct statute as a vehicle for facial challenges to firearms legislation. Separate private challenges remain distinct.

One of two additional federal lawsuits challenging the Montgomery County ordinance was brought by Rabbi J. Menashe Shapiro and the Silver Spring Jewish Center. They argue that the ordinance violates their First and Second Amendment rights, restricts the synagogue’s ability to determine how best to protect its congregation, and discriminates against religious institutions.

In an article in The Reload analyzing the case, Alejandra O’Connell-Domenech writes:

“The ruling is the second in recent months by a federal judge to reject the reasoning underpinning many of the DOJ’s Second Amendment lawsuits, after another judge denied the department’s request for a preliminary injunction against California’s “Glock ban” back in July. The pair of decisions could spell trouble for the DOJ’s larger project of assailing state and local gun restrictions it believes violate the Second Amendment.”

Domenech’s comment could be prescient after the recent announcement of the departure of Harmeet K. Dhillon.

← Hornady’s Welded Gun Cabinets: Steel Security Without the Vault Price Tag
Gun Owners Prepare: Poll Reveals Doubt New Dem Majority Will Behave →
  • Useful Gun Owner Links
    • Armed American Radio
    • Citizens Committee for the Right to Keep and Bear Arms (CCRKBA)
    • Doctors for Responsible Gun Ownership (DRGO)
    • International Association for the Protection of Civilian Arms Rights (IAPCAR)
    • Jews for the Preservation of Firearms Ownership
    • Keep And Bear Arms (KABA)
    • Polite Society Podcast
    • Second Amendment Foundation (SAF)
    • Tom Gresham's Gun Talk
    • US Concealed Carry Association
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • ARCHIVES
  • ABOUT US
Copyright © 2026. All Rights Reserved.